First-Round Bust Rate: What Percentage of NFL First-Round Picks Are Busts?

First-Round Bust Rate – Nearly Half of First Rounds Picks Bust Out

The NFL Draft is one of the most anticipated events in American sports, a spectacle where teams pin their hopes on young talent to transform their franchises. The first round, in particular, carries immense weight—teams invest significant resources, scouting, and draft capital to secure players they believe will become cornerstones of their roster. However, despite the hype and meticulous preparation, a substantial number of these highly touted prospects fail to meet expectations. This raises a critical question: what percentage of NFL first-round picks are considered “busts”? To answer this, we must define what constitutes a bust, examine historical data, and consider the factors that contribute to these outcomes.

Defining a “Bust” in the NFL

The term “bust” is subjective and varies depending on context, but it generally refers to a player who fails to live up to the expectations associated with their draft position. For first-round picks, the bar is high: teams expect these players to become starters if not stars, and to justify the investment with long-term contributions. Several metrics can be used to assess whether a player is a bust:

1. Performance Metrics: One common approach is Approximate Value (AV), a statistic from Pro Football Reference that quantifies a player’s contribution per season. An AV of 5 or higher per year is often seen as a baseline for a decent starter, while 7 or more indicates a good-to-great player.
2. Second Contracts: Another measure is whether a player signs a second contract with the team that drafted them, signaling that the team deems them valuable enough to retain beyond their rookie deal.
3. Career Longevity and Starts: Players who fail to start consistently (e.g., fewer than 50 career starts) or have short, unproductive careers are often labeled busts.
4. Expectations vs. Reality: For top-10 picks, the expectation might be Pro Bowl or All-Pro caliber play, while for late first-rounders, consistent starting ability might suffice.

Given these criteria, studies and analyses have attempted to quantify the bust rate, with results varying based on the definition applied.

Historical Data on First-Round Bust Rates

Research spanning different draft classes provides a range of estimates for the bust rate of first-round picks:

• 53% Success Rate (2011-2017): An analysis of first-round picks from 2011 to 2017 found that 53% (120 out of 223) achieved an average AV of 5 or higher, implying a 47% bust rate. This study sets a relatively low bar—essentially requiring players to be regular starters—yet nearly half fell short. When raising the threshold to an AV of 7 (indicating a good NFL starter), the success rate drops further, with only about one-third meeting this mark.
• 31% Second-Contract Rate (2010-2017): A study by The 33rd Team examined players from 2010 to 2017 and found that only 31% of first-round picks signed a second contract with their drafting team. While this doesn’t mean 69% were total busts—some signed elsewhere or had decent careers—it suggests that over two-thirds didn’t meet their team’s long-term expectations.
• 50% Hit Rate (2000-2019): ESPN’s analysis of drafts from 2000 to 2019, based on second contracts with the original team, estimated a 50% “hit rate” across all positions, implying a 50% bust rate. For quarterbacks specifically, only 38% of first-rounders from 1999 to 2023 were deemed “franchise stalwarts,” suggesting a 62% bust rate at that position.
• Position-Specific Trends: Bust rates vary by position. Offensive linemen (e.g., 83% success rate in some studies) and linebackers (70%) tend to have lower bust rates, while quarterbacks (60-78% bust rate depending on criteria), wide receivers (63% bust/reach rate), and cornerbacks (64%) are riskier.

Averaging these findings, the bust rate for first-round picks likely falls between 47% and 60%, with the higher end often applying to premium positions like quarterback or when stricter success criteria (e.g., Pro Bowl appearances) are used.

Why Do So Many First Round Picks Bust?

The high bust rate isn’t just a matter of poor scouting; it reflects the inherent challenges of transitioning from college to the NFL. Several factors contribute:

1. Evaluation Difficulties: College performance doesn’t always translate to the pros. Quarterbacks from spread offenses, for example, may struggle with NFL complexity, while physically gifted players might lack the technique or mental acuity to succeed.
2. Injuries: High-profile busts like Ki-Jana Carter (No. 1, 1995) and Brian Bosworth (1987 supplemental) saw their careers derailed by injuries shortly after being drafted. Even one major injury can turn a promising prospect into a bust.
3. Team Fit and Development: A player’s success often depends on coaching, scheme, and surrounding talent. David Carr (No. 1, 2002) faced relentless pressure behind a porous Texans offensive line, while JaMarcus Russell (No. 1, 2007) struggled with work ethic and poor organizational support.
4. Expectations: The higher the pick, the higher the bar. A mid-first-rounder who becomes a solid starter might be a success, but a top-5 pick with the same output (e.g., Trae Waynes, 11th overall, 2015) is often seen as disappointing.
5. Luck and Variance: As Ravens GM Eric DeCosta has noted, the draft is “a luck-driven process.” Even the best evaluators can’t predict every outcome, from off-field issues to unforeseen regressions.

Notable Examples of First-Round Busts

To illustrate, here are some infamous first-round busts:

• JaMarcus Russell (QB, 1st, 2007): Touted as a generational talent, Russell flamed out in three years with the Raiders, plagued by poor performance and conditioning issues.
• Ryan Leaf (QB, 2nd, 1998): Picked after Peyton Manning, Leaf’s 14 TD-to-36 INT career epitomizes the boom-or-bust nature of quarterback selections.
• Trent Richardson (RB, 3rd, 2012): A college star, Richardson’s NFL tenure lasted just three underwhelming seasons.
• Akili Smith (QB, 3rd, 1999): The Bengals passed on a haul of picks to draft Smith, who started only 17 games.

Implications for Teams and Fans

The data suggests that drafting in the first round is far from a sure thing. For every Justin Jefferson or Patrick Mahomes, there’s a Zach Wilson or Johnny Manziel waiting in the wings. This reality has led some teams, like the Los Angeles Rams, to prioritize trading for proven veterans over rolling the dice on draft picks—a strategy that paid off with a Super Bowl in 2021. For fans, it’s a reminder to temper expectations: even a “can’t-miss” prospect has a roughly 50-50 shot of underwhelming.

Final Thoughts

So, what percentage of NFL first-round picks are busts? Depending on the metric—AV, second contracts, or positional success—the answer ranges from 47% to 60%, with an average of around 50%. This sobering statistic underscores the gamble inherent in the draft, where even the most heralded players face long odds. As the 2025 NFL Draft approaches, teams will once again weigh these risks, hoping their pick defies the odds to become a cornerstone rather than a cautionary tale. For now, history tells us that half will fall short, a stark reminder that in the NFL, potential is no guarantee of success.

For more discussion on the Los Angeles Rams, please visit The Rams Forum